Climate Change Could Be Worsening Effects of El Niño, La Niña

Global Warming Worsening Impacts; Creating New ENSO ‘Flavors’

By Stephen Leahy*

UXBRIDGE, Canada, Jan 11, 2011 (Tierramérica) 

The strongest La Niña weather system in 50 years has brought historic flooding to Australia and drought to Argentina, Brazil and Uruguay, driving up food prices.

Scientists now believe climate change is likely enhancing the impacts of the famous El Niño-Southern Oscillation (ENSO), a cyclical climate phenomenon that affects weather patterns around the world.

La Niña and El Niño are, respectively, the cold and warm phases of the ENSO cycle, and form part of the system that regulates heat in the eastern tropical Pacific Ocean.

Both accompany simultaneous changes in surface ocean temperature and air pressure.

In conditions defined by climatologists as “neutral,” high air pressure predominates in the eastern Pacific, while low pressure predominates in the west.

This independent environmental journalism depends on public support. Click here learn more.

The difference in pressure generates the trade winds, which blow east to west over the surface of the tropical Pacific, pushing the warm waters westward. The deeper, cooler waters then surface in the east, replacing the warm waters.

During episodes of La Niña, the differences in pressure are more marked, the trade winds blow more strongly, and the cold-water currents in the eastern Pacific intensify.

On the other hand, during El Niño, high surface air pressure in the western Pacific and lower pressure on the coasts of the Americas cause the trade winds to weaken or change direction, resulting in warmer water temperatures in the eastern Pacific.

“There has been a very rapid transition from El Niño to La Niña in 2010,” Kevin Trenberth, a senior climate scientist with the National Centre for Atmospheric Research (NCAR) in the central U.S. state of Colorado, told Tierramérica.

A very strong yearlong El Niño ended last May and within two months switched over to La Niña by July, said Trenberth.

The current La Niña has not only ended Australia’s 10-year drought, but also flooded more than 850,000 square kilometres, an area equivalent in size to France and Germany combined. It also has resulted in flooding in northern South America and brought drought conditions to the middle and southern parts of the continent.

As a consequence, agricultural production has been impacted. Global food prices reached a record high in December, the United Nations Food and Agriculture Organisation (FAO) reported on Jan. 5.

“There have been changes in the El Niño-La Niña cycle since the 1970s. It’s a complex cycle but the associated droughts, flooding and other manifestations have been stronger over the last 30 to 40 years,” Trenberth told Tierramérica.

Since climate change has fundamentally altered the global climate system, trapping more heat and about four percent more water vapour in the atmosphere, it is reasonable to conclude it has affected the ENSO cycle.

“It would be surprising if there wasn’t an effect,” Trenberth said.

It was Peruvian fishers who named El Niño after the Christ child (“niño” means child or boy, in Spanish), since the effects of the warming of the surface waters of the eastern Pacific ocean — such as bringing rain to the dry Peruvian deserts — show up around Christmas.

Over months, and sometimes years, the heat in the surface layer of the Pacific dissipates and the deeper colder water gets to the surface, aided by changes in the trade winds. This results either in a return to neutral conditions or the appearance of La Niña (“girl”, in Spanish), the “gift-giver”, bringing cold, nutrient-rich water that is a boon to marine life, supporting a larger fish population and increasing the fish catch.

Fishers might expect a good year ahead, as a strong La Niña is now dominating the Pacific Ocean. “This is one of the strongest La Niña events in the past half century, and will likely persist into the Northern hemisphere summer,” said Bill Patzert, an oceanographer and climatologist at the Jet Propulsion Laboratory of NASA (U.S. National Aeronautics and Space Administration).

ENSO has a three- to seven-year cycle, with a four-year average to go from El Niño to La Niña, but this varies considerably both in terms of periodicity and strength, explained Trenberth.

Each cycle is different and unpredictable and currently beyond the capabilities of computer climate models to emulate, he said.

While flooding and droughts have become measurably worse, there is no clear evidence that climate change has affected the ENSO cycle itself, for example, by shortening it as in the current cycle, said Trenberth.

Emissions from fossil fuels act like an extra blanket in the atmosphere, trapping additional heat from the sun. Nearly all of that extra heat has gone into the oceans. Since the 1970s, the world’s oceans are getting measurably warmer and that is also likely to affect ENSO, noted Julia Cole, a climate scientist at the Institute of the Environment at the University of Arizona.

Historically, ENSO has had a huge range of variability and the drivers of the cycle are not fully understood, making it very difficult to determine how climate change is affecting it or to predict future changes in the cycle, Cole told Tierramérica in an email interview.

However, the latest research seems to show “that we may even see new ‘flavours’ of ENSO emerge as we move into the future,” she said.

Australia’s La Niña flooding is unprecedented. At least 10 people have died, with damage and losses estimated in the billions of dollars.

Much of the flooding is in the northeastern state of Queensland, whose rivers flow into the Coral Sea, and is expected to have a major impact on the nearby Great Barrier Reef.

Enormous amounts of sediments and pollutants are being washed off the land and are likely to have “a huge impact” on the world’s largest coral reef system, said Charlie Veron, former chief scientist at the Australian Institute of Marine Science.

“The very strong La Niña is certainly causing the floods, but climate change would seem to be enhancing the effects,” Veron wrote in an email.

Queensland’s vast sugar cane fields are drowning, but crops in Argentina, Brazil and Uruguay are parched by drought, pushing food prices to a record high by the end of December according to a FAO report released Jan. 5.

Continued drought in Argentina or winter kill from the severe cold in parts of Europe and North America could combine to drive food prices even higher, the FAO report warns.

Even though much of the southern Pacific has been cold under La Niña, 2010 tied 2005 as the hottest year on record according to NASA’s Goddard Institute for Space Studies.

First published as: Climate Change Could Be Worsening Effects of El Niño, La Niña – IPS

13 thoughts on “Climate Change Could Be Worsening Effects of El Niño, La Niña

  1. Stephen,

    Great piece. A minor correction is perhaps in order for the last sentence. NOAA/NCDC have just reported that 2010 tied with 2005 for the warmest year on record, and they were warmer than 1998.

    Actually, I am surprised that the global temps in NCDC came in as the record warmest– they tend to run a little cooler than NASA GISTEMP. This suggests that the NASA GISTEMP data will almost certainly show 2010 being the warmest calender year, beating out 2005.

    GISTEMP should be out today– although I’m sure Hansen is making sure that their numbers are right given the expected whining of the “skeptics” and denialists.

  2. December 2009:

    Dr Jones said an El Nino event in the Pacific Ocean – linked to hotter, drier conditions in Australia – would have an effect on the world’s climate next year.

    David Jones is the head of climate analysis at the Australian Bureau of Meteorology environment/ scientists-tip-2010-as-hottest-yet-20091209-kk3k.html

    I’m disappointed to read a climate scientist state atmospheric CO2 acts like a blanket, extra or not.

    • A La Nina may indeed bring hot dry conditions next year. And the additional CO2 in our atmosphere may make those La Nina conditions worse – which is the point of the article.

      You do understand the role CO2 plays as a greenhouse gas?

      • My mistake Matt. Jones was correct for the first half of 2010 and then there was an abrupt switch over to a La Nina in June/July – fastest ever and no one predicted that.

  3. In this last of meeting places, we grope together, and avoid speech, gathered on this beach of the tumid river……

    This is the way the world ends, Not with a bang, but a whimper…..

    TS Eliot

    opening quote of the Nevil Shute novel ‘On the Beach’

    • Peter it was an interesting novel and movie but this is not the same because it is within our abilities to limit the impact of by taking action. Best place to start is at home talking to family, friends and neighbours – we’re all in this mess together. and if they’re in denial then point out the major $ savings by using less fossil fuels.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s